| Rev. Carl Linn | SS | 1871 |
| Rev. C.W. Seamen | SS | 1873 |
| Rev. John Launitz | SS | 1881 |
| Rev. Augustus Heibert | SS | 1881-1885 |
| Rev. C.A. Limberg | SS | 1885-1897 |
| Rev. A.C. Espach | SS | 1899-1903 |
| Rev. Arnold G. Sauerbrum | 1904-1920 | |
| Rev. Henry B. Ellwood | 1922-1924 | |
| Rev. Thomas F. Kerr | October | 1924-1929 |
| Rev. C.R. Thayer | 1930-1941 | |
| Rev. J. Leslie Bell | April | 1941-1945 |
| Rev. D.J. Scott, D.D. | SS | 1945 |
| Rev. J.C. McElroy | SS | 1946-1948 |
| Rev. David Thompson | (Student Pastor & regular) | 1948-1951 |
| James Chain - Student Pastor | 1952 | |
| Rev. Ralph G. Coonradt | August | 1952-1959 |
| Rev. Mark B. Maharg | SS | 1959 |
| Rev. Carl F. Schoman | 1960-1968 | |
| Gordon Parke- Student Pastor | 1969-1973 | |
| Rev. Andrew Chalmers | SS | 1973-1974 |
| Ronald Miller | SS | 1975-1978 |
| Rev. Rick Hays | March | 1978 |
| Rev. Jean Henderson | December | 1978-1985 |
| Rev. George H. Kehrli | October | 1985-1986 |
| Rev. Robert B. Langston | August | 1986-1996 |
| Rev. Thomas Clyde - Interim | February | 1997-1998 |
| Rev. Jeff B. Moore | July | 1998-2007 |
| Rev. Robert McCrumb II - Interim | February | 2007-2008 |
| Rev. Toby L. Brown | August | 2008-2011 |
| Rev. James Steiner - Interim | October | 2011-2013 |
| Rev. Jonathan West | June | 2013-2016 |
| Rev. Janet Hufford - Designated Term | February | 2017-2018 |
| Tom McMeekin - Interim | July | 2018-2021 |
| Rev. Mark Allio | July | 2021 |
SS - Stated Supply
